Model the savings on your own well.
What is mechanical specific energy?
Mechanical specific energy (MSE) is the energy the drilling system spends to remove one unit volume of rock. It is a measure of drilling efficiency: the closer MSE is to the strength of the rock, the more of the energy is going into cutting.
Where does MSE come from?
Teale introduced the idea in 1965, defining specific energy as the work done per unit volume of rock excavated (Teale, 1965). Pessier and Fear adapted it for oilfield drilling and showed that minimum MSE approaches the confined compressive strength of the rock when drilling is efficient (SPE 24584).
How is MSE calculated?
MSE has two parts, one from the axial force and one from rotation:
MSE = WOB / A + (120 × π × RPM × T) / (A × ROP)
where WOB is weight on bit (lbf), A is the bit area (in²), RPM is rotary speed, T is torque (ft-lbf) and ROP is rate of penetration (ft/hr). The result is in psi. In practice the rotary term dominates.
What does a high MSE mean?
If MSE is well above the rock's strength, energy is being lost somewhere other than cutting: to vibration, bit balling, poor hole cleaning or a worn bit. A sudden rise in MSE while the rock stays the same is a sign of drilling dysfunction, for example stick-slip.
How do drillers use MSE?
By watching MSE in real time and changing one parameter at a time. If raising weight on bit raises ROP and MSE stays flat, the bit is cutting efficiently. If MSE jumps, the last change pushed the system past its efficient point, which Dupriest called the founder point (SPE 92194). Real-time MSE is also used to detect vibration and bit wear (AADE-17-NTCE-033).
What are the limits of MSE?
MSE calculated from surface data uses surface weight and torque, which can differ a lot from what the bit sees in deviated wells. Downhole measurements give a truer value. MSE also does not say which dysfunction is happening, only that energy is being wasted.
How do you keep drilling close to its efficient point?
NexTitan measures the force it applies at the bit and is designed to hold it steady as the rock changes, to keep drilling closer to its efficient point. See drilling optimization.
To estimate what more efficient drilling would be worth on your section, use the drilling cost calculator.
Drill hard rock with NexTitan
The tool, step by step.
Ask about your well or formation.
